On who owns credibility, and why readers leave.
A post from a media CEO stopped my scroll this week. She asked readers not to applaud the struggles of mainstream newspapers, and not to say proudly that they now read the news online for free. Her argument is that if mainstream media dies, access to reliable information shrinks, because those newsrooms practice the discipline and ethics of verification. And if they go, where will our children get legitimate information?

Part of that is right. Verification, editing, and ethics are real work, and they cost money. An algorithmic feed does not replace them. But I am the reader she is talking about, and the reason I left was not price.
The Trust Went First
I grew up reading The Star to improve my English, and theSun because it was distributed for free. As I got older, I began to notice how closely Malaysian newspapers were tied to political interests—Utusan Malaysia and Berita Harian being among the most visible examples—and I slowly read less. I don’t think my experience is unusual. Nobody tricked me into free news. The trust went first.
It was not just a feeling. UMNO controlled the publisher of Utusan Malaysia for decades, until its stake fell drastically in early 2019. The company shut down that October. Utusan’s own journalists’ union blamed the closure on the party’s interference, while UMNO’s secretary-general at the time claimed the paper’s problems were business problems, not political ones. Berita Harian sits under Media Prima, and UMNO only gave up its shares there in 2019. Whichever account of Utusan’s collapse you believe, the ties were there for readers to see, and readers drew their own conclusions.
Guilt is Not a Strategy
What I still value is what would bring me back: the record of historical events and national occasions, the discipline of the craft, and the long-form pieces and weekly columns by editors and writers who are given room to think. None of that depends on being free or being online. It depends on someone being trusted to do it.
So telling readers not to be proud of reading online for free addresses the wrong cause. A reader who left over trust will not come back over guilt. It also moves the cost of the industry’s mistake onto the reader.
Credibility is a Practice, Not a Masthead
A famous name on the front page verifies nothing, while a reporter who checks the claim does. That practice can live entirely outside the old structures. Malaysiakini launched as a free site in 1999 and successfully moved to a paywall in 2002.
Its CEO has described a revenue model split roughly evenly between subscriptions and advertising, and the outlet publishes its funding—including grants it says never exceed 10 percent of its budget from any single source. Zeteo in the US leans even harder on its 50,000+ paying subscribers rather than corporate sponsors or ad revenue.
What I take from that is more useful than simply “paywalls work.” It proves that no newsroom is free of funding; the question is simply whether the reader is allowed to see it.
The Return Through Visibility
Ownership has changed hands since 2019, but trust lost to opacity does not return just because you swap out the shareholders. It returns through visibility. Organizations like hers are better placed than anyone to rebuild it. They have the editors, the archives, and the reputations. What they must add is plain disclosure of ownership and funding, corrections made in public, and an honest account of how a story was checked.
She asks where our children will get legitimate information, and that is the exact right question. The answer is: from whoever earns the trust and shows the work, regardless of what is printed above it.
Lokman / BIKIN
(Disclosure: I publish on a small independent platform of my own, so I have a stake in this argument.)
