Skip to content

The Gap They Haven’t Seen

On payments, gamification, and the gap digital banks haven’t seen yet.

A Note Before We Begin

This is the fifth part of my Malaysian Digital Banking series. Not an industry analysis. Not a research report. Not a consultant’s recommendation.

Semata-mata pemerhatian seorang pengguna. I am a user and a UX researcher, not an industry insider. I expect to be wrong somewhere.

I had not planned to extend my Digital Banking series to a fifth part. But the recent Fintech News Malaysia report on the current state of digital banks gave me an itch I had to scratch.

The report shows all five digital banks lost money in FY2025. Four of the five are widening their losses while building deposits. Bank Negara allows up to five years in the foundational phase, and to exit, a bank must keep at least RM300 million in capital funds that losses have not eaten. That is consistent with what I have been arguing. It does not prove it.

Over the previous four parts, the hypothesis I have been testing is simple: digital readiness does not equal behavioral readiness. I argued that the Malaysian saver’s identity is built around protecting money, while digital banking was built around moving it. We saw institutions measure pandemic-era eWallet downloads and mistakenly call it banking readiness, building their foundation on a massive sampling error.

Paying Is Not Entrusting
People can use a digital bank, but that does not mean they will move their lives into one. Yes, users will move some money to take advantage of rewards, referral points, and gamification. But that behavior is simply parking money. It is not entrusting it.

An eWallet is an addition to the banking setup you already have; it is low risk, and nothing is displaced. A digital bank asks you to replace your primary bank—your salary, your savings, your history. If I already have a banking app, why would I move? The honest test of trust is your salary: does it land in the digital bank, month after month? I cannot see that number, and neither can you.

The Gamification Trap & The TNG Reality
Right now, digital banks are driving volume through gamification. I use AEON Bank, and the more QR payments I make, the more cashback I get through points and Neko Missions. But this works much like a credit card fueled by your own money. It encourages spending to build daily active use.

Volume, however, is not value. Look at TNG eWallet: scale was never their problem, yet payments alone did not make them profitable. It took them seven years to turn their first full-year profit. The company says it has been profitable every month since September 2024. Profit arrived alongside a shift in which half of their revenue came from outside of payments—wealth management, insurance, and B2B services. My reading is that volume came first, and the profitable services came after. I do not think digital banks have seen this gap yet.

The Tabung Problem
The legacy mindset of the average user remains unchanged: a bank is for saving and building a backup. Digital banks make saving highly visible through digital pots and tabung features. But visible is not the same as protected.

If your savings and daily spending sit seamlessly in one app with no lock-in, I suspect the tendency to withdraw from that tabung is high the moment you hit a cash flow roadblock. AEON Bank’s pots, for example, can be withdrawn anytime in the app. Traditional investments have built-in friction—they take a few business days to clear, or early withdrawals result in depreciated profits. That friction is a feature, not a bug. It actually protects the saver from themselves. Making it too easy to move money defeats the purpose of saving it.

Dashboards Will Not Build a Moat
On the tech side, banks are pushing personalized dashboards to track where your money goes. But as a UX designer, I know this firsthand: replicating what works on a competitor’s UI is the shortest, easiest road to take. These visual features can be duplicated by any banking app. A clean dashboard does not build a defensive moat, and it does not generate trust.

What Would Prove Me Wrong
Digital banks are sitting on the perfect recipe of data, user retention, tech, and personalization. They have everything they need to become an app superpower, yet they still struggle to prove that their model actually works.

Are we looking at this from the wrong angle? Are they trying to close the wrong gap? In macroeconomics, spending indicates growth, and that may be why digital banks chase it. But on the ground, the user’s biggest concern will always be their financial safety net.

What would prove me wrong? Seeing salaries credited to a digital bank, month after month, with balances that remain long after the promotional campaigns end. Until I see that, the diagnosis remains the same:

Volume is not value.

Spending is not saving.

Paying is not entrusting.

Five parts. One diagnosis.

I expect to be wrong somewhere.

That is why I am writing it down.


Founders lose attention for a simple reason.
They write what is right to say.
Not what they actually think.

I help founders close that gap.

Start a conversation →